澳洲同城网

标题: 我也来求评分! g类大作文. [打印本页]

作者: Abracechurbem    时间: 2010-8-9 21:26
标题: 我也来求评分! g类大作文.


开始准备IELTS考试了, 自从有了移民的想法后, IELTS的大作文就一直是我头痛的问题, 一直没有时间好好来倒弄下, 这段时间破釜沉舟了, 每天一练, 希望大家帮忙看看评评分,给点建议哈, 谢谢!<br />
<br />
Topic: Many people migrate from large cities to small towns for lower living costs and better environment, do you think advantage of this development outweigh its disadvantage?<br />
<br />
In modern society,undoubtely whether or not people should migrate from big cities to small regions has become a hot issue of ordinary people's life. The issue has triggered a heated discussion and generated different views. Some people say that is beneficial for people to live in a small town, while others insist that it is not convenient for people to leave large cities and move to small regions. Personally I think the former is more convincing and I would qualify it to some extent.<br />
<br />
Firstly, the environment of large city is becoming more awful. Obviously the small towns are better in environment than the big cities. It is evident that people suffer kinds of terrible diseases in the modern cities as the result of continually exasperating environment. If people move to regional areas, they can be far away from the risk of pollution and keep healthy easily<br />
<br />
Secondly, the living expense in modern cities is much higher than small towns. Probably we can take the house price as the example. The medium house price in Beijing, the capital city of China is approximately $300,000, whereas it is reported that the medium price for buying a house in a small region near Beijing is just about $100,000. It seems clearly that houses in the small region are more affordable than the large modern city-Beijing.<br />
<br />
Obviously, we can not deny the fact that living in small towns has brought us some inconvinience, such as lack of transports, few shopping centers, and few job opportunities. However these have already been history. The public facilities have always been on-going provided and the job opportunities are increasing as more and more people moving to the regional areas. It will be more convinient for people to live in the small towns than before.<br />
<br />
Having considered all the arguments above, we may safely draw the conclusion that migrating from big modern cities to small towns will bring a lot of benefit to people. Most people can have comfortable lifestyle with good environment and less living cost.<br />
<br />
[]




作者: qome2704    时间: 2010-8-9 23:49


Some people say that it is...
Obviously the environment in small towns are better...
It is evident that people suffer different kinds...
as a reuslt of the continually...
they can be/stay far away from...
It seems that OR It is clear that houses in small region...
modernised city - Beijing.
a lot of benefit(s)...



作者: 中国强能也    时间: 2010-8-10 07:50


审题: do you think advantage of this development outweigh its disadvantage

首先要搞清楚 问的是你对&nbsp;&nbsp;development&nbsp; &nbsp;的看法。。你文中讨论的是哪里住更好。。

第二。。确定你直接对应回答了蓝色句子的问题了么?..你文中说。。“我”更支持前面的观点。 然后该观点也只是说“beneficial for people to live in a small town”。



作者: 宫长剑    时间: 2010-8-10 14:44


5分



作者: uskv5353    时间: 2010-8-11 00:37


undoubtely should be undoubtedly, right?



作者: Abracechurbem    时间: 2010-8-11 07:36


谢谢指正。



作者: Abracechurbem    时间: 2010-8-11 19:33




我觉得我应该是有回答了蓝色句子的问题,Body段的前2段写了从城市搬到small towns的advantage, 一个是环境,一个是房价;第3段写了disadvantage,生活可能会不方便,缺少公用设施,然后话锋转过来说这些问题已经成为历史,生活配套设施在small towns也不断地改善,为后面结尾认为搬到small towns住更好。

能够讲下您对这个topic的思路么?谢谢!



作者: Abracechurbem    时间: 2010-8-11 19:43


谢谢指正,呵是undoubtedly.



作者: Abracechurbem    时间: 2010-8-12 05:52


&nbsp;&nbsp;don't scare me~~~any points?



作者: 衣工坊1    时间: 2010-8-12 11:50





首先要说的是,这个topic&nbsp; &nbsp;经常考,1月份才考过。 然而 topic&nbsp; &nbsp;一致并不等于题目一致,反而不认真有针对性地写文章,很容易给人抄袭背诵的感觉。

再谈你是否回答直接蓝色部分句子的问题:
如果先撇开不看题目。我和你做一个会话的练习。 你对应回答:&nbsp;&nbsp;Do you think today's weather is better than yesterday?
你怎么回答我? 对你的第一句回话,我是不是该 expect:&nbsp; &nbsp;yes&nbsp;&nbsp;or&nbsp;&nbsp;No&nbsp;&nbsp;? (准确点是不是说: I think so/ I don't think so)
还是: 今天几度? 或者 “别人说: 今天下雨了”

最后谈是否针对红字回答:&nbsp;&nbsp;我觉得题目的中文解释是: (有这样一个既定事实)现在很多人从大城市搬到小城镇,以便减少开资。。。等。&nbsp; &nbsp;现在问:&nbsp;&nbsp;你是否觉得这样的“发展/演变”是好处多于坏处?

既定事实已经存在,不是要你比较&nbsp;&nbsp;城市好还是城镇好。 不需要你比较它们的环境消费如何。

可是 如果你分析这个既定事实,,对城市高度的住房需求有所缓解, 促进城镇发展,降低城乡差异。 诱导政府发展交通。 舒缓城市交通拥挤,有助降低污染。。。我个人认为i那才是对 development&nbsp;&nbsp;本身好坏的分析。

仅供参考。

[]



作者: enquicite    时间: 2010-8-12 17:58


我觉得这个文章有5.5到6分吧。

我上次作文结尾没时间了,就草草一句结尾了。文章的词汇方面还不及这篇文章。给了5分。
我觉得这个文章应该更好一点。基于以上理由,我给出5.5到6分得估计。

我觉得文章基本cover住了主题,我对题目的理解是,现在很多人为了降低生活开支和居住环境都从城里往乡下跑,这些优势是否能大于不足的因素。
main body 第一句是说乡下比城市环境好。然后核心句是说远离疾病有利健康。主题不突出。
&nbsp; &nbsp;&nbsp; &nbsp;&nbsp; &nbsp;第二部分是说乡下开销小,举例说房子便宜。
&nbsp; &nbsp;&nbsp; &nbsp;&nbsp; &nbsp;第三部分说乡下有诸多不便,但是这些都会随着人口和市政的发展,不成为问题。
end&nbsp; &nbsp;&nbsp; &nbsp;&nbsp; &nbsp;&nbsp; &nbsp; 重申乡下比城里好。

我觉得如果要提高,从我的角度来说,文章的structure不太像八股的essay风格,更多的是咱们的中式作文。而且brainstorming的不够,不能从多个方面比较城市和乡下的优劣。
文中提到了environments,life cost,work opportunities,traffic等几个方面,但是前两个是题目中已经列出的,后面两个factors又揉在一起没有比较论述。如果更拓展一下考虑到children education,social efficiency,ecological effect等因素,分一个段落分别比较论述,是不是更靠近essay八股的风格啊。

这是我这段时间看successful writing proficiency的一些体会。
我上次作文考试,就参考了这些书中所讲的essay structure 的。

sentence structure上面也有提高的空间,修饰限定等成分不够丰满。如果句子丰满一点,字数同时也就上去了。

以上仅供参考,本人也是在学习中,互相交流,一起进步。

[]



作者: Abracechurbem    时间: 2010-8-13 02:49




醍醐灌顶啊!看来我真是把写作对象给搞错了~十分感谢这位大虾,我得回头改去了。 刚注册没发加分好像~先欠着呵。



作者: 暮色天泪    时间: 2010-8-13 10:21


怎么感觉这篇文章是模板套出来的?
使用模板需谨慎啊。



作者: Abracechurbem    时间: 2010-8-13 18:15


您分析的很好,我很受启发,特别是在brainstorming方面,一些话题不敢展开,因为自己的单词量还不够,所以就套用了题目中出现的两个点:environment and living cost, 看来还是要转成其他方面的点来做比较,不然可能也会被考官认为是抄题目了。 还有sentence structure方面我也觉得复杂句欠缺,句式比较死板。 另外有一点我比较担心的是,每次我写作练习,感觉字数都远远超出TASK 2要求的250字,大概都要有320-350字,这样会不会被认为字数过多而扣分,而且写作时间又不够呢?



作者: Abracechurbem    时间: 2010-8-13 21:24


我开头结尾都是套模板,看上去比较死板, 倒数第二段的结构也是套用模板的~ 模板还没有用活~现在慢慢在改进。







欢迎光临 澳洲同城网 (https://www.tongchengau.com/) Powered by Discuz! X3.2