澳洲同城网

标题: 雅思大作文一篇,求高手批改 [打印本页]

作者: 蕙心小筑    时间: 2010-11-28 11:08
标题: 雅思大作文一篇,求高手批改


Some people think high-school graduates should travel or work for a period of time before they go to university. To what extent do you agree?<br />
<br />
Answer:<br />
<br />
Educational issue is a never outdated topic of discussion. Now, let us focus on whether high-school graduates need tour or work for a period of time before they start their undergraduate days.<br />
<br />
No doubt that travel and work can expand our vision and enrich our experience of occupation, live and how to deal with other people even how to tackle trouble. Especially, these experience are plenty important to the students who will take relevant majors in their universities.For instance, a student who has participated job as an electrician that he or she would be superior to his/her peers in the electronic course.<br />
<br />
However, their advantages would just stay in which they have experienced, whereafter, they begin reveal their weaknesses. When a student is enjoying his/her travel or repairing a damaged car, his/her peers are memorising equations in a maths class. That maybe create a gap of basic education between he/she and his/her peers. On the other hand, during their travelling or occupational time, they would be in trouble. Which, some terrible things could traumatize them at an early age. As a consequence, when they graduate from university, they would not more outstanding than their peers.<br />
<br />
Speaking for myself, the tertiary-level education is a approach to the students' career life and play a crucial role in their future. Students' grasp of what has been taught is a sword that they can wield to confront challenge. Further more, Students can earn the experience of travel or work on their summer vacation and winter vacation rather than spend their school time.<br />
<br />
今天花了一小时左右写的,包括自检时间,把能改的差不多改过了。顺便问一下,估计就这样的文章能拿几分呢?<br />
<br />
[]




作者: 1187017584    时间: 2010-11-28 21:58


用词有点高深,我很多看不懂的...
自觉资历不足,就先不评论了。



作者: fi213448    时间: 2010-11-29 09:54


比我水平高



作者: uyshua6112    时间: 2010-11-29 11:59


没说至少要写多少字吗?



作者: vincent问谁呢    时间: 2010-11-29 14:21


1、字数不够
2、读起来很难follow,观点好像不明确,每段好像也没什么topic sentence和supporting的evidence,是我没看懂吗



作者: njtianyuan    时间: 2010-11-29 21:13


1. 使用了不少高级词汇,但是一些基础词汇的使用仍不准确,如最后一句的spend,‘rather than spend their school time.’, 这句话我其实没有读懂。
2. 语法小错不断,如主谓一致,如‘plenty important ’等等,基础语法还需要加强
3.逻辑比较混乱
4. 连贯性也不好

愚见: lz应该在逻辑和连贯性上多下功夫,词汇和语法的话稍微注意下就好了,尤其词汇还是不错的(比我好多了)  

[]



作者: outlet79    时间: 2010-11-30 01:55


词不在深,达意即可. 太追求难词新词反而容易超出自己的控制能力往往容易导致失分
望lz在基础上多下点功夫,少犯小错误一定可以拿到更好的成绩.拿最后一段来说,和结构与内容相比,语法错误可能更影响最后的评分.
Speaking for myself, the tertiary-level(一般不加) education is an approach to the students' careers life (去掉)and plays a crucial role in their future. Students' grasp of what has been taught is a sword that they can wield to confront challenge. Further more Furthermore, Students can earn the experience of traveling or work on their summer vacations and winter vacations rather than&nbsp;&nbsp;instead of spending their time in school.

[]



作者: 杨柳飘逸    时间: 2010-11-30 05:08


如果是练习的话,可以先练好introduction。

e.g.

Education is not everything about school activities. Travel or work experiences can direct a school leaver in what area he or she is to receive tertiary education, though they may play a superficial role sometimes.



作者: 1143332522    时间: 2010-11-30 08:48




附议。词汇只是评分标准的一个方面,其他方面比如题目的完成度(比如通篇都没有明确指出你倾向于哪个论点),论证的说服力(用了一些想当然的东西做论据,当然我承认这个题目的确不好写)还有语法等等与词汇有着相当甚至更高的重要性。所以请楼主请在追求词汇量的同时务必多加注意这些方面

[]



作者: 蕙心小筑    时间: 2010-11-30 14:57




谢谢,看来我要多练习一下基础语法了。



作者: 蕙心小筑    时间: 2010-11-30 21:08




...rather than... 意思是:...而不是...
是十天作文里的高分词汇,和instead of用法类似,但更高级点。
eg: condemn rather than condone sth. 谴责而不是去容忍...
we should condemn rather than condone deforestation



作者: xnbmjgogp4    时间: 2010-12-1 09:02


模式化,喜欢用大词,对新词大词缺乏掌控力。而另一方面基本语法有问题,两者显得不搭。
不是我刺激你,但的确需要加油!
所以楼主还是有很大的提升空间的!



作者: 溜达12    时间: 2010-12-1 19:46




不好意思,之前因为没太看懂这句话顺手改了. rather than应该可以,但是spend school time的用法需要改.
祝lz取得好成绩



作者: nmwdop749n    时间: 2010-12-2 06:26


再提另一点意见,这个隐藏的比较深所以好像很少有人注意到,但是这是个很关键的给分点。题目上说的是travel or work for a period of time before they go to university,而lz阁下的作文里有三个句子/分句:“When a student is enjoying his/her travel or repairing a damaged car, his/her peers are memorising equations in a maths class.” “when they graduate from university, they would not more outstanding than their peers.” 和 “Students can earn the experience of travel or work on their summer vacation and winter vacation rather than spend their school time.” 这三句话都是同时期的打工的学生和入学的学生的比较,给人的感觉是作者认为打工就会导致部分课程的缺席,是“打工而少上学”而非“先打工后上学”。而这是和题目不相符合的。如果考官遇到这样的句子,轻则判为语句有歧义而导致逻辑性失分,重则判为跑题,直接划到5分以下了……所以这个问题专门提出来,希望lz阁下注意



作者: 木子映月5    时间: 2010-12-2 07:11


看了几回,实在忍不住插几句。如果LZ只追求 6分,请注意 脚步和 眼角方向 一致,不要看点太高而忽略平稳走路的重要性。以下是个人的拙见。

相信LZ 花了很多时间和精力才把这篇文章写出来,并拿到 论坛来 接收评价。可是,文章无意义的套句 套词 太多而又用法不规范,反而影响 “流畅” 感。 结构不严谨,或者说无意义的堆砌句子过多,造成乏味,唐突感。让人觉得缺乏中心,重心,甚至离题。毕竟考试时间有限,如果平时练习就没有真正掌握语言的运用,考场上很难在短时间准确表达,很容易造成所谓的“失准”。

语法/单词先暂时不提,先来看看结构的灵魂: 首段,末尾。
题目是问:“To what extent do you agree”

再看你的首段:
“Educational issue is a never outdated topic of discussion. (与教学有关的issue 多着呢&nbsp;&nbsp;?请具体指出什么issue。这是一个空乏的句子,而且用法还不当:&nbsp;&nbsp;topic [ for] discussion. 通常开头最好是单刀直入,哪怕是换个法子,复述题目所叙述的background)
Now, let us focus on whether high-school graduates need tour or work for a period of time before they start their undergraduate days.”
(叙述完background,回到题目本身:问的是你在多少程度上赞成****, 可是你的重点却是: 让咱们来讨论***是否应当。所以我问:你扣题了吗?)

最后一段:究竟你回答了:To what extent do you agree 没有? 毫无侧重的列举观点让人不知所云。要知道最后一段也是最后给读者/考官留下印象的一段。最重要的是,我无法把你最后一段所列举的观点与文中第二第三句的“潜在”中心 一一对应起来。

关于主干的机构:
第二段第一句话就跟不规则的石头的堆砌物——中心不突出。 没有总结句,让人无法扣住第二段的实际中心。
第三段:“However, their advantages would just stay in which they have experienced, whereafter, they begin reveal their weaknesses. ”又是一句空乏的句子,究竟是什么 advantage&nbsp;&nbsp;什么 weakness&nbsp;&nbsp;请用准确的单词明确指出---你可以认为这是显示你词汇掌握的时候了。最后“可能的”总结句“when they graduate from university, they would not more outstanding than their peers”。。Why?究竟会是什么:trouble,terrible things ?&nbsp;&nbsp;这次都太空乏了。请明确列出。

最后总结:文章言辞造句太过空范。缺乏中心,缺乏严谨的流畅结构。不扣题。





作者: 蕙心小筑    时间: 2010-12-2 12:37


一语惊醒梦中人,还有十天要考试了,所以现在每天练两篇一大一小作文。
其实对我来说何谓新词,旧词,大词不是分得很清楚。
我的英文说穿了最后一次在课堂上上课还是在初中,经历了第一鸭的惨痛教训,花了一年时间特地跑回去找老师把还给她的英文能拿多少拿多少回来,然后恶补了近5000词汇量,所以对我来说除了初中以下词汇,其他都算是新词。
现在也许就是练习对这堆新词的反应力和准确度了。
不过通过不断地输出(说和写),我觉得比输入(听和读)更能提升词汇的应用能力。
也许,当我能写出几篇语法错误较少的作文时,我相信应该能扣题了。
很感谢你的批评,让我受益颇多。如果有兴趣的话,能帮我看下跟帖的另一篇作文吗?




作者: 蕙心小筑    时间: 2010-12-2 22:57


There are more problem with students' behaviour in many countries. What are the causes and what are your solutions?
write at least 250 words

Answer:

It is not uncommonly that some of students severely violate discipline in some countries, even the incidence of juvenile delinquency is increasingly high. In my opinion, some factors probably could cause this phenomenon.

Currently, increasing publication and movies are inundated with violent and pornographic contents, which could lead students to simulate what they have watched. Underage students have not enough ability to control themselves or to know whether it is right or not. Likewise, the domestic violence is the same dangerous &quot;teaching material&quot; to afflict children with frustration, misery and loneliness. As a result of it, children would treated other peers like what they has been seen, even if not so, they would be accompanied by the burden of gloomy childhood memories in their lives.

Therefore, in my view, we could take steps to reduce these phenomenoa to the limit. For the sake of that we necessitate the force not only government but parents to make a concerted effort to improve the current circumstance of children's growth. The authorities could make some strictly legislation against gratuitous violent and pornographic contents to minor, as well as the laws against domestic violence. In terms of household, parents should take more time off for their children and guide rather than punish them when they committed a mischief.

In conclusion, youngster are, by nature, undeveloped、innocent and pure, sometimes they are just the passive receptacles of predigested ideas. It is guidance and care that can lead them to the correct ways. We should give priority to improve the phenomenon because they are our children at present and they are our future as well.



作者: hussau51sf    时间: 2010-12-3 05:11





3WU一直是改作文的明星级老师:)。。。建议LZ根据3WU的点评,再把原先那篇作文改改,重新写一下,改自己写过的作文我觉得比不断新写作文效果好。LZ加油,祝你十天后顺利通过哈:)



作者: 头越来越大    时间: 2010-12-3 06:17






[]



作者: ocxrjkpw2    时间: 2010-12-3 16:12




实在很希望能给你高分做鼓励。可是面对 如此之多的简单语法错误,严重用词不当,逻辑序乱,我实在不忍心给你打高分。要是很走运也许有 5.5-6。毕竟结构还算可以。

不知道你写这么一篇文章要多长时间,建议同一个题目,重新恰时间再写一遍。

你用了很多生僻单词很可惜用法并不怎么恰当,而且往往把该用名词的变动词,该用动词的变名词。
e.g.“It is not uncommonly ” 不绕口么?&nbsp;&nbsp;为什么不简单点: It is commonly believed that ,&nbsp;&nbsp;正确与否是用 “tell”&nbsp;&nbsp;的
“which could lead students to simulate what they have watched.” 原句翻译: XXXX 会导致学生们激发他们所看到的内容。。&nbsp;&nbsp;修改: which could influence children's negative behaviour。
如果只要求6分,建议踏踏实实地使用 熟练掌握的词汇。

“As a result of it, children would treated other peers like what they has been seen” 后面句子独立。请用句号/分号;
修改:“######### would treat other peers in a way ” they have learned from media”

&quot;they would be accompanied by the burden of gloomy childhood memories in their lives&quot;&nbsp;&nbsp;why?&nbsp;&nbsp;逻辑问题。

到此,不再一一列举了。建议你自己细心修改---几乎每一个句子都能挑出毛病来(尤其注意你所用的名词,动词)

我觉得你是在不顾一切地堆砌不熟悉的词汇,而不考虑它们的实际用法。想想考官一天要改多少文章? 突然来一篇每一句都坑坑洼洼,尽是生僻单词而又到处语法错误,思路不符逻辑。 你想考官什么心情?

通常清晰的思路/结构,简单而正确的词句,有逻辑的推理/例证是高分作文最基本的要素。

[]



作者: 07z3v8r0q    时间: 2010-12-3 21:30


3wu的点评入木三分,我就只能狗尾续貂了...

我先说需要改进的地方。
简单语法错误太多,像youngster可数,committed a mischief时态不对这种错误相信lz自己可以检查出来的。
主要原因一个是不细心,另一个也是因为用了太多难词最后时间不够了吧?

建议lz降低行文的难度系数,留更多的时间改正语法错误会有更好的效果。
慎小疑不是也说对于自己不是很有把握的词不要贸然去用吗,用对了不一定加分,但是错了一定会扣分,扣多少看老师心情了。比如give priority to后面不是接不定式,对你可能是难词,但是对老师是再普通不过了,这个错误在老师那里会看着会很扎眼的,莫不如不去用。用难词的目的是为了向老师展示自己的实力和高水平,而不是向老师暴露自己的不足。

平时练的时候追求难度是为了提高自己,我觉得有好处。但是现在你快上考场了,应该做考前准备,如果你有100分的难度,就按80分来写,这样才能控制的游刃有余,反倒可以发挥的不错。最后的关头还给自己施压,很容易让文章超出你的控制。

从整体上来看,文章还是不错的。切题正确,report文章按点题-原因-对策-结论 四段格式来写,中规中矩。
Linker也用的不错,基本上都能平滑衔接,看不到突兀的罗列句子。句式变化比较丰富,插入语,非限定,双否,强调都用到了。只要lz心态放平,控制好自己的难度,一定可以取得理想的成绩。

本人能力有限,评论的不足之处欢迎大家指正。



作者: 蕙心小筑    时间: 2010-12-4 00:42


实在感谢楼上几位的分析,improve the phenomenon 还有什么更好的表达方式吗?



作者: 9mf6f177    时间: 2010-12-4 10:36


phenomenon 通篇用了3次,复数phenomena 还写错了,建议少用点,替换成battle / tackle this issue或者make tangible improvement你看行不行?



作者: ovzq5050    时间: 2010-12-4 15:00




遇到蓝眼睛不用害怕,在考场上不是和我们一样坐一样的凳子吗,而且一般他们都很友善,比当年八国联军友善多了。
要是遇到蓝皮肤那才应该害怕~



作者: 蕙心小筑    时间: 2010-12-5 01:59




也不尽然,上次遇到的那个疑似终结者5,由始至终都没有任何表情,我朝他笑他就问我要ID Card,可能是扫描到我一笑就和照片上不一样了,之后我也受到感染,不仅不笑,还和他说中文。



作者: 94u0c0j0t    时间: 2010-12-5 12:18


值得肯定的是楼主学习能力还是很强的,从过去基础很薄弱到现在能够用上很多大词,词汇量还是足够的。

感觉楼主最大的问题其实是输入不够,这里输入主要指的是原汁原味的文章,句子。你可能短时间内背了很多词汇,然后用中翻英的方法对应相应的英文词汇堆在一起,这样的效果如同电脑翻译软件,你可以试着把英文的文章拿翻译软件翻成中文试一下,估计咱们看起来还是有困难的。我猜考官读你文章的感觉也差不多类似,第一篇文章不超过5分,第二篇有进步,潜力很大,不知道你得目标是几分,呵呵。

的确反复输出可以提高熟练度,就是中翻英的熟练度,而且你也提到了练输出比输入感觉提高的快。但是没有足够的输入,输出是不可能成功的。输入需要下功夫,如果你时间短,不妨背范文,要native写的范文,再背一些句子。背的多了你就会有感觉什么样的句子是地道的,什么是中式英语,还有一个办法就是把你的每个句子放到google上搜一下,如果没搜到,就说明不地道,同时还能找到相近的搜索结果,人家都是native,可以学习别人是怎么说的,一举两得。

你一次考试听力和阅读分数都不够好,还是说明输入差的比较远,对于中国人来说,听力阅读得6以上比写作和口语容易。当然那是一年多前的成绩了,希望你已经有很大进步。



作者: 蕙心小筑    时间: 2010-12-5 21:29


谢谢楼上高人指点,说得太准了。其实真正开始做练习的时候是在一个月以前,以前一直在背。
当开始做练习是就发觉和你说的情况基本差不多。
以前一直以为词汇才是提高英文的方法,还和老外聊了很多,但那个毕竟是聊天,就算只蹦出一个单词,只要达意他们就能知道你的意思。
但现在是考试。需要有板有眼的时候我就很难组织起一句地道的句子了,这时候才发觉不是那么简单的事情。
感觉一个月真是少了些,我要争取在7/1前拿到四个六,最差也得平均6分。
感觉自己也在进步,都已经苦过来了,不会放弃的。



作者: dsafsf    时间: 2010-12-6 09:28


lz继续加油



作者: 蕙心小筑    时间: 2010-12-6 14:00




  







欢迎光临 澳洲同城网 (https://www.tongchengau.com/) Powered by Discuz! X3.2