澳洲同城网

标题: 论坛新手,求鉴定g类task 2作文! [打印本页]

作者: 雨过天晴驾小船    时间: 2012-2-27 15:58
标题: 论坛新手,求鉴定g类task 2作文!


2010年考过一次A类,4个6。。。好平均,两年没看过雅思了。最近动了移民澳洲的心思,需要考个G类,试写了一篇,自己觉得烂得不行,但不知道怎样提高。请各位拍砖指教。顺便给个客观点的评分,让我心里有个目标。BTW,我剥了4.21的考试,北京的<br />
<strong>Topic:<br />
Some people prefer to live in a house, while others feel that there are more advantages to live in an apartment.<br />
Are there more advantages than disadvantages of living in a house compared with living in an apartment.<br />
Give reasons for your answer and include ay relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.</strong><br />
<br />
With the living condition getting improved in many countries, people can afford to live in a house,instead of living in an apartment.These two kinds of housing have their own advantages and disadvantages.<br />
<br />
Living in a house gives people more room and space than living in an apartment, which could allow people to enjoy anything they are interested in without worrying about disturbing their neighbours. Also, most house are built with gardens and garages, therefore, people can relax their bodies and souls when they feel tired and stressed generated from job or other unpleasant things. And in modern cities, like Beijing, parking location is increasingly rare and hard to get when parking. Consequently, having a private garage looks more important , which would allow you not to spend much time on finding location to park.<br />
<br />
However, there are some drawbacks to living in a house compared with living in an apartment, in my point of view. Normally, houses are built in countryside or some place where there are not neighbours around your house, which could make people feel lonely and get alienation from neighbours. What’s worse, people might get psychological problems due to less communication with other people. In contrast, people living in an apartment have more chances to communicate with others.<br />
<br />
In conclusion, in my opinion, I would prefer to live in a house because more space ,private garage are priority for me when deciding where to live.




作者: 雨过天晴驾小船    时间: 2012-2-27 20:43


自己带头顶一个!刚才数了一下,字数238.。。。NND。。。



作者: 雨过天晴驾小船    时间: 2012-2-27 23:45


没人理。。。



作者: 2351233    时间: 2012-2-28 02:32


写的很好啊,一雅作文5.5的学习来了



作者: 雨过天晴驾小船    时间: 2012-2-28 11:39


感谢楼上鼓励,希望更多筒子提建议



作者: 70gwt1sfy1l    时间: 2012-2-28 15:29


写的不错。。。。但是不知道评分多少,还没有考过哦。。



作者: 雨过天晴驾小船    时间: 2012-2-28 20:06


请更多筒子批改啊~~~



作者: refa3551    时间: 2012-2-29 05:29


比较严重的问题是逻辑漏洞很大,就算有车库出去停车一样要找车位,house也不总是盖在荒无人烟的地方。论述和conclusion没有明确的必然相关性,在某一个具体的advantage和disadvantage上缺少足够的横向比较。



作者: lq7b7dypy    时间: 2012-2-29 06:19


同意8楼的点评!

我个人觉得,这篇文章可能只有6分。因为,作者只比较了住在别墅里的好处和坏处,但是没有详细地论证和住在公寓里相比,住在别墅里的好处是大于坏处的。而这一点是这篇文章的关键。

你看啊,题干问的是Are there more advantages than disadvantages of living in a house compared with living in an apartment. 关键词是:more/advantage/than/disadvantage/living/house/apartment。在这里面,我的感觉啊,最关键的是一个more和than.

所以,写的时候,或许应该是这样的:

body-P1: living in house 的各种advantage。同时,用一两句话点出living in house的disadvantage
body-P2: 让步+承接,承认living in house 的disadvantage恰恰是living in an apartment的advantage. 然后,立即转折,尽管living in apartment有这样一些有点,但是, 也有很多缺点啊,比如说。。。。。。

Conclusion:在我看来,因为什么什么对我来说最为重要,所以,即便living in house有一些小的缺点,但是它的优点还是远远大于其缺点的-点题

再说一下楼主的第二段:看起来好像没有主题句。英语的论文,正文阶段每一段都要有主题句.之后,这一段里的任何一句话都要起到补充说明/解释/阐述/定义/拓展主题句的作用。

另外,楼主的第三段,虽然有主题句,但是在后面的支持句里,论证的还不够伸入。所以看起来,第三段的字数和论证效果就差一些。搜一下论坛里yrqin同学发的《step bu step剖析雅思写作》

最后,我觉得楼主的语法没有什么大问题。我个人觉得如果40分钟的时间可以写出来这样的水平的话,评分标准里语法这一项肯定可以拿到6或者更好。要想确保语法和词汇都拿到7的话,注意一些固定句型和修辞吧。确保每一篇文章里能有一些倒装,强调,虚拟,名词性从句,同位语,分词,被动语态啥的,就没问题了。

加油,祝你好运!



作者: 雨过天晴驾小船    时间: 2012-2-29 16:35



感谢大侠的详细点评。其实我当时脑子里只有一个大概的架构,里面的内容都是直接写的,还有语法小错误。您指出的主题句、让步+承接、没有对Living in an apartment的描述不够都是这篇作文的致命缺点,我会在这几方面努力改进的.BTW,能被评价个6分我已经比较满意了,呵呵。因为我觉得短期内我4个6差不多,4个7估计够呛呢。再次感谢!



作者: 雨过天晴驾小船    时间: 2012-3-1 04:06



嗯。其实我写车库的时候也琢磨来的,但实在没论据可写了,呵呵;结论那块确实牵强了;横向比较指的是house和apartment的好坏处的比较?



作者: 雨过天晴驾小船    时间: 2012-3-1 09:42


顶起,大家继续拍哈







欢迎光临 澳洲同城网 (https://www.tongchengau.com/) Powered by Discuz! X3.2